Success in the ESU Mace Debating Competition

PGS has enjoyed a strong start to this year’s English‑Speaking Union Mace schools’ debating competition, with two impressive performances across the opening rounds.

Round 1 at PGS

The first round took place on Tuesday evening in the atmospheric surroundings of the Memorial Library, which proved an excellent venue for a night of high‑quality debating. Representing PGS were Anna B (Year 12) and Vivaan D and Samuel VDB (both Year 13), who argued as the proposition for the motion: “This House Would ban short‑haul domestic flights where transport alternatives exist.”

Facing Ryde School with Upper Chine, the team delivered a thoughtful and well‑constructed case in what became the standout debate of the night. Both schools qualified for the next round, alongside St Swithun’s, Winchester.

Mr Wickes, Head of The Portsmouth Grammar School, who attended the event, praised Samuel’s summary speech as the highlight of the evening—well‑deserved recognition. The team represented the school superbly throughout and can be congratulated on progressing in this prestigious competition.

Thanks also go to Ruthie G, Hannah H (both Year 12), and James M (Year 13), who officiated brilliantly as timekeepers and Master of Ceremony, ensuring the smooth running of the event. It was an excellent night of debating—certainly closer than last summer’s competition, which required a long journey to Taunton.

Round 2 in Salisbury

The momentum continued on 28 January 2026, when a PGS team travelled to Bishop Wordsworth’s School in Salisbury—just a stone’s throw from the city’s famous cathedral—to compete in Round 2. The speakers for this round were Ruthie G, Anna B, and Samuel VDB.

The motion debated was: “This House would hold tech companies legally responsible for the mental health impact of their platforms.” PGS took the Opposition stance, presenting a clear, balanced, and well‑reasoned case that provided a calm counterpoint to the hosts’ more emotive approach.

A special commendation goes to Ruthie, who stepped in at the last minute and delivered a confident, composed, and compelling speech—an impressive performance under pressure.

The team debated superbly throughout, and we are delighted to report that PGS not only won the debate, but also secured one of the two qualifying spots for the regional final, which will take place on 18 March at Badminton School, Bristol.